by | Amusement (↓) | Skill (↑) | 0 comment | 2 questions

originally a national public service to provide healthcare for the whole population of the UK, now being increasingly privatised by the government with the publicly owned parts increasingly underfunded and criticised for failing.

Where and how is it used?

In doctors' and dentists' surgeries, clinics and hospitals by people stay well or to get well if they're sick and injured.

What did you or someone else pay for it?

Probably thousands of pounds over my lifetime in taxes and National Inurance contributions

Why do you want to add it to the museum?

Because it's rapidly becoming a commodity, not a service

How was it made?

Is made in a factory

Is farmed

Is mass-produced

Is produced by local cottage industry

Is made to particular specifications

Is craft / hand-made

Is foraged

Is found

Is colonised

Is a service

Materials & Making

Who made or produced your commodity?

Many people

Who was paid to make it?

The state

What skills does it take to make it?

Too many to list here

Where was it made?

In the UK

What does it cost to make it?

Currently £116.4 billion a year

What is it made from?

1. people, equipment, drugs, dressings:

Buying & Owning

Who decides how much it costs?

The government

Who or what assesses its quality?

The government, NHS England, local Clinical Commissioning Groups, patients

Where is it sold?

Under our noses

Who or what sells it?

A Tory government

How did this thing arrive from where it was made to where you got it?

By intelligent politicians realising we needed a healthy population

Where is it used?

Everywhere in the country

Where is it kept?

In surgeries, clinics and hospitals

How and by whom is it cared for?

By civil servants in the Ministry of Health, NHS England, members of CCGs and its employees

How long will it last?

Not much longer if the Tories have their way

Where will it go when it's finished with?

Into history

What is it worth?

Fighting for

How do you and others value this commodity?

See the values contributed by visitors and those of the donor. And add your own values to this commodity.

Total times valued8
Positive (↑)Skill
Negative (↓)Amusement
Overall Positive1054
Overall Negative-164
Controversy67.75 (0 = most controversial)

What do these numbers mean?

This data that we have collected over time in our database means nothing without interpretation. A relational database, which we are using here, is technology that enables designers of websites and software to compare, contrast, interrogate and infer relations within data. The act of designing a database is not objective but driven by the agency of its creators and owners.

Within the MoCC Collection data is used to help think through the relations between values, commodities and data. Can we describe our values using sliders and numbers? How do we infer meaning such as controversy from data?

Below is a brief explanation of the some calculations and how these help make decisions about what is shown on the site.

  • Controversy Score:
    (Total Positive Values) + (Total Negative Values)

    The closer the value is to zero the more controversial it is in relation to other commodities. Used to infer that values associated with one commodity divide opinion more than another.

  • Average Value Score (used in the sliders):
    (Total Positive for Value + Total Negative for Value) ÷ Total Times Valued

    Used to infer a collective value associated with a commodity.

How do you value this commodity?

To add your own values click VALUE THIS COMMODITY and move the sliders left and right to add your own values - then click SUBMIT
show donor's original values
- 0
76 +
- 0
78 +
- 0
68 +
- 0
69 +
- 0
67 +
- 0
60 +
- 0
61 +
- 0
61 +
- 0
54 +
- 0
55 +
- 0
45 +
- 10
58 +
- 3
40 +
- 0
20 +
- 0
38 +
- 0
38 +
- 2
39 +
- 17
50 +
- 14
32 +
- 0
10 +
- 5
7 +
- 17
19 +
- 16
0 +
- 17
4 +
- 25
5 +
- 38
0 +

Questions and answers

Help to reveal unknown quantities, properties and uses of this commodity by answering this MoCC curator's questions.

Question: What do you think it's worth?



My name is Alice and I’m your commodity consultant for today.

What do I think the NHS is worth? This maybe one of the more difficult questions I am going to answer today as our relationship with the NHS is bound so tightly with our experience with it.

If we look at it on a purely monetary perspective the NHS has a planned expenditure of £116.57bn for 2015/16. (http://bit.ly/1kXa3DA). While this sounds like a lot, it is only 6.2% of UK GDP (http://bit.ly/1XH5Kgs).

However, its founding principle in 1948 that “the health service will be available to all and financed entirely from taxation, which means that people pay into it according to their means” (http://bit.ly/1pqBfwc) is something which I don’t think you can put a price on. It’s sentiment comes from a place often forgotten by modern day politics, that everyone has a right to be treated the same as everyone else, without having to justify why.

Lets dig a little deeper by looking at my relationship with the NHS.

So, I am a 26 year old female who is of good health the majority of the time. Prone to the occasional headache and, as any other 26 year old with a decent social life, likes to skip over the ‘how much do you drink in a week question’, when filling out a health form.

I recon on average I go to my GP once, maybe twice a year, and have had a total of four trips to A&E (that I can remember) and 1 surgical procedure. According to the Guardian NHS cost calculator this costs the NHS:

GP costs: £999 a year
1 x broken arm after tumble at Glastonbury - £500
3 x Concussions (while most people rebelled in their teenage years, I played contact games and had a habit of falling down stairs) - £390
1 x Tonsil removal - £1090

So far the running total for my 26 years on earth is £25,974.

Source: How much do I cost the NHS?

But, there is more. I also have a port wine stain, or birthmark for short. It runs from my right hand side of my face, down my body and right arm across to my left leg.

“A port wine stain is a vascular birthmark caused by abnormal development of blood vessels in the skin. A port wine stain is sometimes referred to as a capillary malformation. A port wine stain is a flat, red or purple mark on the skin that is present at birth.”

Source: Port wine stain

It causes me few problems nowadays, other than the odd dodgy look from an intrigued passers by, but when I was a child, around other children who are not known for their tact, it could make me feel very self conscious.

“Laser treatment is the only treatment for a port wine stain. It lightens the affected area of skin. Laser treatment often works better in younger children because in adults a port wine stain may become bumpy and raised after a number of years.

The most common type of laser treatment is known as pulsed dye laser treatment. The laser passes through a fibreoptic cable. On the end of the cable is a device that looks like a pen. This is gently held against the surface of your child's skin and a button is pressed, which sends a beam of light to the skin.

The light goes less than 1mm into the skin. It's absorbed by the blood vessel just beneath the surface, causing it to heat up. The heat damages the blood vessel, which creates a bruise that will fade within a week or two.”

Source: Birthmarks Treatments

So far I have had 30 or more treatments under a general anesthetic and 16 or more without it. While there are no given numbers to calculate the cost we can take the conservative figure of £500 per general anesthetic with an additional £100 per laser treatment (http://bit.ly/1TN38rJ) at a total cost of £19,600. In total I have had more than £45,574 from the NHS, which doesn’t even include all the extra appointments and check ups that are too long to list.

Yet, the real value of the NHS is not the cost of my treatment, it’s the fact that the cost of the treatment doesn’t come into it. The real worth of the NHS for me is that they provided me with a treatment which did not save my life, but made my life a lot easier to go on as normal. That is a ‘worth’ which I will never be able to put a price on.

by MoCCconsultant on May 21st at 1:59pm

Question: Is it Invaluable?


Most definitely!

by Jules on May 18th at 6:49pm

It is both invaluable and sadly undervalued by many.

by Delia Webb on May 19th at 2:30pm


Do you have questions about how this commodity is valued? Or want to talk about your own values in relation to it? Share your comments.

Add to the conversation: